Nearly 1 in 4 Americans Forced to Choose Between Bills and Basics

A recent survey from Experian highlights the scale of the credit problems facing American households: 23% of adults report carrying what they describe as “unmanageable” debt, to the point that they must choose between paying creditors and covering basic living expenses.

Despite that troubling statistic, the same data offers cause for optimism. Forty-five percent of respondents say they have successfully moved past a period of unmanageable debt, and many report a measurable improvement in mental wellbeing after regaining control of their finances.

Survey respondents describe a range of practical steps they’ve taken to address debt. Common approaches include taking on extra work or side gigs to increase income, prioritizing certain balances to accelerate payoff, and using budgeting tools and apps to track spending and reduce unnecessary expenses. These strategies often work in combination: increased income paired with focused repayment plans and stricter monthly budgets has helped many households reduce balances and avoid falling back into distress.

The survey also identifies a widespread misconception that contributes to persistently high balances: thinking that making only the minimum payment on credit accounts is an adequate long-term strategy. More than two in five people surveyed admitted that this belief was their biggest misunderstanding before learning how to manage debt more effectively. In reality, minimum payments can prolong repayment periods dramatically and lead to much higher interest costs over time.

Experian’s findings underline two clear messages. First, a substantial portion of the population remains at risk of severe financial strain, and targeted support for those households is needed. Second, many individuals can and do change their financial trajectory through a mix of increased earnings, disciplined budgeting, and strategic repayment—actions that also tend to produce better mental health outcomes.

For policymakers, employers, and community organizations, the survey suggests opportunities to reduce household financial stress: expand access to financial education that clarifies the long-term consequences of minimum payments, promote tools that simplify budgeting and debt tracking, and support programs that help people increase earnings or access affordable repayment plans. For individuals, the survey reinforces that manageable, sustainable progress is possible when practical tactics replace harmful misconceptions.